Welcome to New Story Coffee House
Nestled at 352 E Main St, Mt Pleasant, PA, New Story Coffee House is a charming retreat for coffee lovers. This cozy establishment is celebrated for its expertly crafted espresso drinks and homemade syrups, which set it apart from typical coffee shops. Customers rave about the inviting atmosphere, attentive staff, and community spirit fostered by owners Rachel and Keith. With a play area for kids and a menu that includes delicious smoothies and treats, it’s a perfect locale for families and individuals alike. Whether you seek a comforting latte or a serene spot to unwind, New Story Coffee House promises a delightful experience.
- 352 E Main St, Mt Pleasant, PA 15666, United States Hotline:
Welcome to New Story Coffee House, a delightful gem located at 352 E Main St, Mt Pleasant, PA, where passion for coffee meets an inviting community spirit. Tucked just off the Donegal exit off the turnpike, this cozy haven has quickly become a favorite among locals and travelers alike.
As soon as you step through the doors, you are greeted with the warm smiles of owners Rachel and Keith, who pour their hearts into every cup they serve. Their commitment to quality is evident in every sip, with beautifully crafted espresso drinks that boast rich aromas and velvety textures. The care taken in making their coffee, including house-made syrups, sets them apart from the typical big-brand cafes. Many customers rave about their iced mocha and signature lattes, with one enthusiastic reviewer declaring that the coffee here might be the best they've ever had.
But New Story Coffee House is more than just fantastic coffee. It features a welcoming atmosphere perfect for family visits, complete with a play area for kids that allows parents to relax and enjoy their treats. With options that cater to different tastes—whether you crave a refreshing smoothie, a comforting cup of tea, or a decadent homemade blueberry muffin—there’s something for everyone.
The charm of this coffee house extends beyond its menu. Regulars have described it as a place where you feel like family, and the genuine connection fostered between staff and patrons creates a sense of belonging that is hard to find elsewhere. The loving atmosphere, combined with a focus on community, transforms a simple coffee run into a moment of joy.
In this quaint space, you’ll not only savor exceptional flavors but also engage in meaningful conversations, whether it’s a playful chat with the friendly barista or bonding with fellow coffee aficionados. The simple decor adds to the homey feel, making it an ideal spot for solving puzzles, catching up with friends, or simply indulging in a moment of tranquility with your favorite drink.
In a town previously lacking quality coffee options, New Story Coffee House has rejuvenated the local coffee scene, providing a refreshing alternative to gas station brews and chain cafes. Their meticulous attention to detail and unwavering dedication to service remind us that every cup of coffee tells its own story, celebrating the art of coffee making while weaving together the fabric of community. We can't recommend this place enough—it's worth every visit.

If you love coffee you will love this place! If you are on the turnpike it is just a short jaunt down the mountain side from the Donegal exit. (Toward Mt. Pleasant) There is a lot of care and thought that goes into a cup of coofee at New Story Coffee House. I travel to many places and am always looking for a good cup. This is my favorite by far. They also have great smoothies and teas. There are many options for different needs.

We love this place! We come every time we are visiting family in town. Great coffee. Great treats. And truly wonderful owners and staff! They also have a play area for kids so parents can sit and enjoy their coffee while the kids are preoccupied. Highly recommend stopping in!

Hands down the best local coffee shop! The owners and the barista are all such wonderful people! They make you feel like family every time you stop in. And the coffee and food are so good! They make all their syrups in house, which sets their coffee apart from other coffee shops! If you have not tried New Story yet, I highly recommend you do so!

Desperately needed coffee while traveling. Discovered New Story along our route, and it was perfect! The iced mocha and homemade blueberry muffin were delicious and hit the spot! Staff were very kind and helpful. Definitely recommend!

My only regret is i can't live next to this real style coffee house. It looks like a salon house after you leave town so hard to find but a gem. Right after the train tracks and then another hill and as you decend it is on the right. Heard them in the back cleaning when i came in wed afternoon. They even chatted me up even though i only had a custom made beautiful latte with scratch syrup. Try it out and give them money. It is so good and i was so thrilled to see the barista making it with care. Seriously best place to get a coffee maybe ever. It is like someone is serving you in their living room.

Fav coffee shop. They make the best coffee and have such inviting people working there. Perfect spot to do a puzzle and enjoy your latte

During a somber weekend visit for my fiancee's grandmother's funeral, we stumbled upon New Story Coffee House, and it turned out to be a true silver lining in a difficult time. We've frequented Mt. Pleasant on multiple occasions over the years, always lamenting the absence of quality coffee shops. The options were limited to gas station brews or the recent Dunkin'. However, New Story Coffee House has single-handedly changed the coffee game in this town. Rachel and Keith, the heart and soul of this cozy haven, made us feel right at home. Their warm and welcoming demeanor provided a glimmer of solace amidst our trying circumstances. Their understanding and kindness were deeply appreciated, and it made our visit feel like we were among friends. Now, let's talk about the coffee – the true star of the show. Mt. Pleasant was long devoid of a place to savor expertly crafted espresso-based drinks. That is, until New Story Coffee House stepped in. The coffee here is nothing short of excellent. Every sip is a testament to their dedication to the craft. The rich aroma, the perfectly pulled shots, and the velvety steamed milk all come together harmoniously. To Rachel and Keith, your dedication to quality, your warmth, and your inviting coffee house have left an indelible mark on us. We'll definitely be back whenever we're in town, and we encourage everyone to support this wonderful establishment. A cup of their exceptional coffee is more than a beverage; it's a sip of comfort and a testament to the power of community coming together. I look forward to see how the space/place evolves with more seating, food options, etc.! Thank you, New Story Coffee House, for giving us a new reason to smile in Mt. Pleasant.

This is our go-to every morning whenever we're in the area. The espresso is some of the best tasting I've ever had, including my own! The owners are very friendly and knowledgeable about coffee and are extremely meticulous about making customers drinks to order. The place is clean with nice simple decor. Would definitely recommend to anyone who is looking for a better alternative to the big brand coffee shops.