New Story Coffee House Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to New Story Coffee House, a hidden gem nestled in Mt. Pleasant, PA, where quality coffee reigns supreme. Specializing in expertly crafted espresso-based drinks, this cozy haven elevates your coffee experience with homemade syrups that add a unique touch to your favorite brews. The owners, Rachel and Keith, pour their hearts into every cup, ensuring that each sip is infused with warmth and dedication.

But the menu doesn’t stop at coffee; there are delightful smoothies, refreshing teas, and an array of scrumptious treats to satisfy your palate. Families will appreciate the kid-friendly play area, making it a perfect spot for both parents and children to unwind. With a welcoming ambiance akin to enjoying coffee in a friend’s living room, New Story Coffee House is not just about beverages but creating memorable moments.

Whether you’re seeking solace or a caffeine fix, this inviting space promises a new chapter of comfort and community in Mt. Pleasant. Don’t miss out on what customers are raving about—visit New Story Coffee House for an unforgettable experience!
Food Items
Seasonal Drink Specials
Smoothies
All Iced Drinks
Hot Coffee Drinks
Other Drinks

Food Items

Garden Fresh Bagel Sandwich

Cucumber and Tomatoes fresh from the farm, seasoned with basil, salt and pepper, and cream cheese on a toasted bagel.
US$6.00

Muffins
US$3.75

Bagel With Cream Cheese
US$3.75

Breakfast Burritos

Ham, egg, and cheese.
US$5.00

Comfort And Joy Latte (Orange, Rosemary, Cardamom, Star Anise, Cinnamon)
US$4.00

Blissful Delight (Cherry, Vanilla)
US$4.00

Peppermint Mocha Latte
US$4.00

MayFlower Latte (Lavender, Chamomile, Sage)
US$4.00

Mojito Latte

Cafe Latte, infused with our homemade lime and mint syrups.
US$4.00

Strawberry Latte
US$4.00

Rosemary Meadow (Rosemary, Vanilla, Honey) Latte

This latte boasts fragrant rosemary, creamy vanilla, and sweet honey.
US$5.00

Forever And Always Latte (Fig And Pistachio)
US$4.00

MayFlower (Chamomile, Lavender, Sage) Latte

Chamomile, lavender, and sage dance in a creamy latte.
US$5.00

Hazelnut Latte
US$4.35

Bonfire Latte (Maple, Cardamon, Ginger, Star Anise, Cinnamon)
US$4.00

Lemon / Lavender Latte
US$4.00

Turkish Delight Latte (Rose & Vanilla)
US$4.00

Cozy Morning Latte (Chai, With Vanilla Simple Syrup, Steamed Milk)
US$4.00

Pumpkin Spice Latte
US$4.00

Heartbeat Haven (Strawberry, Vanilla, Chocolate)
US$4.00

Foggy Morning (Earl Grey Tea, VanillaLavender Simple Syrup, Steamed Milk)
US$3.50

Autumn Love Latte (Apple, Caramel, Cinnamon)
US$4.00

Gingerbread Latte
US$4.00

SnickerDoodle Latte (Vanilla, Nutmeg, Cinnamon, Brown Sugar)
US$4.35

Cupid's Comet (White Chocolate, Caramel, Raspberry)
US$5.00

Blueberry Sky (Blueberry And Vanilla) Latte

A velvety symphony blending bold espresso, rich vanilla, and sweet blueberries.
US$5.00

BlackBerry Latte
US$4.00

Winter Cheer Latte (Juniper Berry & Cinnamon)
US$4.00

Maple Cinnamon Latte
US$4.00

Raindrops On Roses (Rose, Cardamom) Latte

Experience aromatic rose and exotic cardamom in a luxurious latte.
US$5.00

Seasonal Drink Specials

Smoothies

Aloha Pineapple

Lemongrass, spinach, kiwi, cucumber, kale, banana, apple, spirula, pineapple & pear.
US$2.75

Summer Strawberry

Strawberry, pear, apple, pineapple, acai, goji berries, areola & maqui berry.
US$2.75

Mellow Mango

Apple, pear, banana, pineapple, vitamin C, selenium, Echinacea.
US$2.75

Sunny Banana

Banana, apple, pear, pineapple, oats.
US$2.75

Iced Cafe Latte
US$4.50

Nitro Cold Brew

Medium.
US$6.00

Iced Matcha Latte
US$5.50

Iced Tea
US$3.00

Iced Cafe Americano
US$3.00

Iced Chai Tea Latte
US$5.50

All Iced Drinks

Hot Coffee Drinks

Cafe Americano

Espresso and water
US$2.75

Double Shot Espresso
US$2.75

Cafe Latte

Espresso and Milk
US$3.85

Cortado
US$3.00

Drip Coffee
US$2.00

Tea Latte (Fog)
US$3.00

Chai Tea Latte
US$3.75

Hot Chocolate
US$3.00

Tea
US$2.00

Matcha Latte
US$3.75

Other Drinks